Little Fish, Big Impact

 

Menhaden-illustration-w-striper_PewCharitableTrusts_695x352
Menhaden are the fuel of the Bay's food web, providing critical sustenance to other Bay species like rockfish. Graphic courtesy of The Pew Charitable Trusts.

Small, silvery, and packed with nutritional might, menhaden have long been thought of as "the most important fish in the sea." And the other week, they once again came to the forefront of fisheries management and Chesapeake conservation.

On October 26, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC), which manages the coast-wide catch of menhaden and 23 other migratory fish species, met in Bar Harbor, Maine, to revisit menhaden's harvest cap for next year

Menhaden are a fundamental link in the Bay's food web, serving as valuable sustenance for striped bass and many other important fish, marine mammal, and seabird species. Their health directly affects the health of the entire ecosystem. Yet the menhaden population has faced a long history of large-scale industrial fishing and historic low abundance in recent years.

We sat down with Bill Goldsborough, CBF's Fisheries Director and former ASMFC Commissioner, to get a better understanding of what happened at the meeting, and what it means for the fate of this all-important fish.

 

What happened in October?
ASMFC took up the issue of what the menhaden quota should be for 2017 after delaying the decision at its August meeting. A compromise was reached to increase the current harvest cap by 6.5 percent, bringing the menhaden catch limit up to 200,000 tons. That number was judged to be the middle ground among nine different options considered in August, ranging from keeping the status quo all the way up to increasing the catch limit by 20 percent. This quota is only for one year before the new management plan (or Amendment Three) comes into place in 2018.

 

What does this mean?

It's disappointing. With menhaden still not abundant throughout their geographic range and continued concerns about recruitment in the Bay, staying the course would have helped ensure a healthier menhaden population for all stakeholders�the reduction industry, bait fishermen, anglers, conservationists, etc.

What's more, we're not being consistent with the objective that the ASMFC has had for 15 years to account for menhaden's ecological role, something the commission is planning to do in 2018 by adopting "Ecological Reference Points" (ERPs) under Amendment Three. (ERPs are guardrails for managing the harvest while leaving enough menhaden in the water for the ecosystem.) The bottom line is there was too much political pressure to have an increase right now.

IStock_000013646856small_osprey & menhaden
A hungry osprey with his menhaden lunch. Photo by iStock.

Why are menhaden so important?
Menhaden are the fuel of the food web, and we control the flow. Too low and we have problems with striped bass nutrition, diseases, mortality, and so forth. For a predator like striped bass that depends a lot on menhaden, if there are not enough menhaden available, they will shift to something else that's probably not as nutritious. They might shift to blue crabs�is that better for the bigger picture? It's a tradeoff between management objectives. You have to think in an ecosystem-sense rather than a single-species context for ecologically important fish like menhaden. It's important to remember that leaving menhaden in the water to be eaten satisfies an important management objective to keep the ecosystem healthy. You get incredible value from leaving these fish in the water.

What's next?
ASMFC will develop a new menhaden management plan (Amendment Three) for 2018 based on public comment from all stakeholders as well as scientific data and expertise.

This new plan will give us ecological reference points, and it will give us a new framework for allocating the menhaden catch quota among the states, among the industries, and so on. Right now it's done by state�each state gets a certain percentage of menhaden catch, and Virginia gets 85 percent out of the entire coast, while some states get less than one percent

One type of ecological reference point that CBF and many other groups support would maintain at least 75 percent of the virgin biomass [how many fish would be in a natural system before any harvesting] in the water for the health of the ecosystem.

The first public comment phase on the new menhaden management plan ends January 4, 2017. Click here to take action now for the Bay and "the most important fish in the sea" before the January 4 deadline!

This year is a big year for you. You're retiring as CBF's Director of Fisheries next month after 38 years and leaving ASMFC after more than 18 years on the commission. What has been the biggest milestone for you, particularly in your time with ASMFC?
Actually getting a quota on menhaden with Amendment Two was the biggest milestone that I was part of at ASMFC. And if Amendment Three proceeds the way it's supposed to, that will probably supersede Amendment Two as a milestone.

Before Amendment Two, there was no limit on the catch of this ecologically critical fish. No limit! And it was the biggest fishery on the East Coast, and annually in the top five nationwide�West Coast, Gulf Coast, Alaska. That's high volume! Getting a quota set at a conservative level�20 percent below what it had been�was probably the biggest milestone for me.

There's been a whole lot more focus on the importance of forage fish in general in recent years, and I think a lot of that derives from the two decades that we've been working on menhaden.

Over the next few weeks, ASMFC is holding public hearings about its revised menhaden management plan. Stand up for this important fish at one of the public hearings in Maryland, Virginia, and other coastal states. Click here for the full list of hearings.

�Emmy Nicklin
CBF's Senior Manager of Digital Media

Learn more about menhaden and why they are so important at our next Blue Planet Forum.

 

Emmy Nicklin

Issues in this Post

Fisheries   Sustainability  

Comments (1)

From: wty123 on June 13, 2017

remorse adidas issued. iphone 4s cases Someday asics parents nfl bengals jerseys gone, ray ban black friday can true religion jeans outlet make omega their bulls jersey own ray ban conscience, nfl ravens jerseys it polo outlet online would barbour jackets outlet be much iphone 5s cases pleased kate spade bags heart. toms outlet Money will jimmy choo come air jordan and nfl cowboys jerseys go, michael kors but nfl chiefs jerseys the situation lacoste outlet is extremely heavy, MO washington wizards jerseys yourself ray-ban sunglasses regret timberland shoes doing versace things. doudoune north face Huijia jordan retro see, tommy hilfiger online listen to soccer jerseys their nagging, understanding nfl rams jerseys what their nfl steelers jerseys parents juicy couture clothings alone, not plein shoes to swarovski crystal let air max 2007 a north face busy oakley word sad asics gel emotion. calvin klein outlet The same cheap michael kors day tn requin pas cher we will grow old, phoenix suns jerseys will have oakley the coach outlet store same michael kors purses lonely, air max 90 when beats by dre headphones children ralph lauren outlet online Huijia michael kors bags see coach outlet if nuggets jersey we can, coach bags outlet what we nike free touch givenchy the adidas.nl face michael kors outlet of ralph lauren polo the vicissitudes of longchamp handbags life, nfl jaguars jerseys there true religion is no mcm handbags white adidas shoes hair cle Jerseys count burberry handbags increase, tommy hilfiger I nike jordan think pandora the moment air max pas cher is vibram five fingers happiest.Postscript:In nfl eagles jerseys the old times, burberry sale we go hogan back to uhren shop those nfl dolphins jerseys years, nike air max and air force these oakley store emotional oakley sunglasses cheap way, but polo ralph lauren outlet it hogan shoes is converse the coach outlet heart timberland pas cher of our nike roche greatest mbt shoes wealth. longchamp Treasure christian louboutin every encounter, nhl jerseys every edge treasure, nike air let vans us huarache on hermes belt the michael kors outlet online sale emotional journey barbour of life planted lebron james shoes the louboutin shoes seeds rolex watches out in nfl jerseys Maybe we'll burberry outlet play ralph lauren outlet money to easton bats their mlb jerseys parents bcbg max azria from louboutin shoes time nike free trainer 5.0 to supra shoes time, but think hogan sito ufficiale about it, atl jerseys they really need is michael kors the ray bans money? They supra shoes outlet want to adidas online shop see nike free is hermes birkin bag the coach factory family mcm bags reunion, bcbg max they huarache are ralph lauren uk no hollister online shop less than michael kors outlet online give coach outlet online that burberry handbags love, burberry handbags that northface idea! basketball shoes In fact, true religion jeans women we ecco mens shoes really that adidas busy? nike shoes Busy coach outlet store entertaining? Busy jordans playing prada cards? true religion jeans outlet Or nfl lions jerseys are air jordan shoes working toms outlet overtime nike roshe run every ray ban outlet day? mavericks jerseys Maybe michael kors we polo ralph can nike roshe run find a ray ban sunglasses variety nfl jets jerseys of air max thea reasons to cheap barbour jackets stall excuse golden state warriors parents oakley sunglasses look longchamp outlet back, oakley holbrook but burberry outlet online a michaelkors.com lot burberry outlet of cheap true religion things to nfl saints jerseys himself nike air max understand ralph lauren black friday that michael kors black friday parents rolex watches do michael kors not nike air max say rolex watch mouth, p90x3 heart wholesale handbags to hermes birkin understand, jerseys from china because ferragamo the new york knicks jersey old adidas online shop also cheap jordans lacks pandora charms the nba jersey capability. new balance Once mcm backpack in ray ban outlet television ray ban prezzi public designer handbags service new balance store ads utah jazz jerseys to reebok see michael kors bags such ray-ban sunglasses a michael kors outlet online sale picture, coach factory outlet with deep feeling, a detroit pistons jersey girl air max happy new balance shoes to nike mercurial give louboutin shoes his mother ralph lauren called nike id and ray ban said; rockets jerseys Mom, oakley do huaraches not kate spade handbags go bottega home ralph lauren outlet this pandora bracelet year, tory burch sale Chinese new orleans pelicans jerseys New michael kors handbags Year, polo ralph lauren outlet busy! You giuseppe zanotti sneakers get oakley some rayban good cheap oakley food. ralph lauren Put michael kors outlet down michael kors handbags the nba jersey phone burberry outlet online the cheap ray ban old man celine outlet online on nike factory crutches, nike shoes repeating ferragamo shoes the dsquared2 shoes word red bottom shoes "child michael kors purses busy." tory burch sale The celine outlet phrase coach shop factory "children hilfiger outlet busy" oakley outlet is full christian louboutin of replica watches much spurs jerseys frustration orlando magic jerseys and armani watches worry. chi flat iron He nike store stood ralph lauren outlet online a wedding dress table full michael kors outlet of delicacies barbour outlet store that roshe they ray ban pas cher be toms shoes outlet able converse outlet to eat it? nba jersey In hollister clothing store the omega watches end thomas sabo we really woolrich clearance understand minnesota timberwolves jerseys how brooklyn nets much adidas clothings parents?Life nfl 49ers jerseys is the north face too air jordan retro short longchamp not air max shoes to burberry outlet online let cheap oakley sunglasses busy ignoring miami heat jersey the mens hoodies family, converse sneakers a "filial son nfl buccaneers jerseys wants hugo boss his parents mcm bags wait" tommy hilfiger online shop is feeling nike outlet much jordan retro 11 the spring eyeglasses frames of nfl seahawks jerseys gorgeous toms shoes outlet ......Zen, oakley sunglasses outlet there michael kors outlet online is clippers jerseys a very north face calm flat iron and burberry outlet online relaxed kate spade outlet mind. philipp plein clothes Body in swarovski online shop the tory burch mortal coach black friday world, mlb jerseys the michael kors heart of ray bans the Pure the north face outlet Land, prada outlet Red nike roshe run Dust, oakley vault Bliss swarovski just valentino shoes a chrome hearts clothings dream. Birds nike nest burberry Jackson michael kors says: prada shoes "to polo ralph lauren go nike shoes without a hermes tracksuits trace true religion outlet without cheap ray ban a under armour outlet trace, salvatore ferragamo and memphis grizzlies jerseys go polo ralph lauren outlet online to soccer shoes outlet events together; louboutin Bliss nfl azcardinals jerseys asked wholesale handbags why ray ban wayfarer more nfl jerseys thing, this prada sunglasses is only nfl redskins jerseys a coach outlet dream nfl giants jerseys Floating toms.com Life." Master marc jacobs handbags Lianchi air max Foji ralph lauren uk said: north face backpacks "Dust vans shoes Network Yiyi dozens oakley sunglasses cheap of long champ spring, yesterday nike factory outlet this burberry handbags is nfl titans jerseys not 76ers jerseys required longchamp black friday on non-;. omega watches Qi nfl falcons jerseys pay air max interest toms.com only nike uk forget nike air max confidant, for toms shoes the burberry outlet online love north face outlet of my nike roshe run House Natsuki yin nhl jerseys "I coach factory online think, nike soccer shoes in ferragamo the mizuno mortal lakers jersey body, adidas zx the oakley black friday total can milwaukee bucks jerseys not timberland boots get rid of earthly entanglement, babyliss flat iron as air max is new balance the same nfl bills jerseys with new balance Zen, cheap michael kors calm longchamp and polo ralph quiet," ralph lauren and tommy hilfiger outlet lovers dre headphones , happy kate spade handbags to do baseball jerseys things, tory burch handbags Mowen converse is jimmy choo outlet stolen michael kors bags is omega watches the edge, toms shoes outlet "live in indiana pacers jerseys the polo ralph lauren moment, marc jacobs handbags in nfl texans jerseys the moment long champ of barbour mens jackets love, ray ban uk happy ed hardy moment, nfl colts jerseys revel, burberry with tommy hilfiger outlet stores the nfl bears jerseys case, nike with hornets jersey the north face jackets nature ray ban pas cher of oakley standard issue this sacramento kings jerseys life cheap coach purses is boutique clothing enough.Love Going hollister co without levis outlet saying "Life pandora jewelry and hollister death nike air max 90 deed wide, shoes outlet and coach outlet usa sub-gracious. Hold hands, free running and dsquared2 sale cried," michael kors uhren just montre femme "a timberland outlet lifetime air yeezy of easton bats at ralph lauren factory store least tommy hilfiger canada one time instyler that north face canada you nike outlet forget pumas yourself pandora charms for toronto raptors jerseys someone, louboutin shoes asking for swarovski canada no thunder jerseys result, juicy couture handbags no mcm backpack outlet company nfl raiders jerseys , prada handbags no michael kors outlet online ownership, montblanc or ray ban sunglasses outlet even nfl chargers jerseys ask you puma online shop love cheap eyeglasses me, just swarovski jewelry in my oakley pas cher most nike beautiful years, michael kors outlet online sale met coach outlet online you "revel beats headphones friend," hollister clothing I hollister kids will pandora jewellery australia visit salomon my thomas sabo only coach factory outlet crowd oakley sunglasses soul mate coach bags friday vast;. purses and handbags too, portland trail blazers jerseys I fortunately; I giuseppe zanotti can cheap oakley sunglasses not, celtics jerseys my rolex replica life. air max 95 "this student horloges favorite fendi shoes Xu chic nfl panthers jerseys and romantic, nike running shoes his hollister co love coach factory outlet online and michael kors outlet online poetry, michael kors handbags fascinated my beats by dr dre whole oakley outlet online life, nfl browns jerseys loved swarovski crystal his nfl vikings jerseys innocence, ray ban love nfl packers jerseys his talent, vans love nfl broncos jerseys him veneta like

nfl patriots jerseys

Share Your Comments

   Please leave this field empty
Stay up to date about the Bay!




DISCLAIMER

PLEASE READ OUR TERMS OF USE

The views and opinions expressed in the media, articles or comments on this site are those of the speakers or authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions held by CBF and the inclusion of such information does not imply endorsement by CBF. CBF is not responsible for the contents of any linked Web, or any link contained in a linked Web site, or any changes or updates to such Web sites. The inclusion of any link or comment is provided only for information purposes. CBF reserves the right to edit or remove any comments and material posted to this website and to ban users from the site without notice. Partisan, pornographic or other inappropriate content, product or service promotion, foul language or bad behavior is expressly forbidden and will be removed.


Support the Chesapeake Bay Foundation

Your donation helps the Chesapeake Bay Foundation maintain our momentum toward a restored Bay, rivers, and streams for today and generations to come.

Donate Today

Save the Bay

Founded in 1967, the Chesapeake Bay Foundation (CBF) is the largest independent conservation organization dedicated solely to saving the Bay.

Save the Bay