Why Don't Farmers Just Do It?

The following appeared on field conservationist Bobby Whitescarver's blog. For more information, please visit his website.

Gerald Garber, Shenandoah Valley dairy farmer. He and his partners fenced two and half miles of streams.

Why don't farmers just do it? I mean fence their cattle out of the streams. If farmers would do this one practice, at least in the Shenandoah River watershed, agriculture would probably be finished with its part of the Chesapeake Bay TMDL.

Excluding livestock from streams is possibly the single most effective Best Management Practice in animal agriculture.

Cows in the stream pollute the water with manure, urine and pathogens.  They trample the stream banks causing sediment to clog the waterways which destroys the aquatic ecosystem.  That's why the Environmental Protection Agency and the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality are pressing farmers to do more.

Many farmers have already done it.  In Augusta County, Virginia for example there are at least 365 farms that have installed stream side buffers.  All of us should be very proud of these farmers because they are the ones that have helped agriculture achieve much of its nutrient reduction goals to restore the Chesapeake Bay.

There's a lot more to do though and I have heard many say, "I'm not going to do it until someone makes me"�.

Gerald Garber, part owner of one of the largest dairies in the valley said, "We all know what needs to be done, we need to do it."�  He added that his cows are healthier and the stream banks have healed since they fenced their cows out of two and half miles of streams.

Excluding livestock from a stream is not rocket science.  Putting up a fence and making water flow into a trough for a cow is pretty easy "� it's the cheapest sewage treatment plant in the Chesapeake Bay watershed.

There are federal, state and private funds to help the farmers get it done.  Last time I checked there were eight programs available to help farmers implement the practices needed to make it work for the farmer.

One of the most popular programs in Virginia reimburses the farmer 115% of the cost to do it and pays the farmer rent on the land they fence along the stream.  The rental rate in the Valley is between $90 and $100 per acre per year "� more than double what the average rental rate is for pasture in most counties.

So if their livestock would be healthier and they get reimbursed for doing it and they get rent on the land they fence, and we know how to do it, why aren't the rest of the farmers doing it?

Is it because they don't want change?  Is it because they don't want government intrusion?  Is it because they don't think their cows pollute the stream?  Is it because they aren't going to do it until somebody makes them do it?  Is it because it's their land and they think they can do what they damn well please?

It's all of the above.  And all these issues are social issues not technical or financial issues.  It boils down to attitude and ethics.

When these remaining farmers (and all of us for that matter), acquire the ethic that it's their responsibility as an owner of land and as a steward of the land, to manage their soil and water resources so that it does no harm to others downstream, agriculture at least will have done its part in restoring the streams in their watershed and the Chesapeake Bay.

--Bobby Whitescarver  

Whitescarver is a recently retired USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) conservationist who spent more than 30 years working with farmers on conservation practices. He now has his own private consulting business where he helps landowners create an overall vision and plan for their land. He also works with CBF to help famers install more Best Managment Practices (BMPs) in the Shenandoah Valley. He is the recipient of a CBF Conservationist of the Year award. For more information, visit his website

Emmy Nicklin

Issues in this Post

Agriculture   Community   Conservation   Federal Farm Bill   CBF in Virginia  



The views and opinions expressed in the media, articles or comments on this site are those of the speakers or authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions held by CBF and the inclusion of such information does not imply endorsement by CBF. CBF is not responsible for the contents of any linked Web, or any link contained in a linked Web site, or any changes or updates to such Web sites. The inclusion of any link or comment is provided only for information purposes. CBF reserves the right to edit or remove any comments and material posted to this website and to ban users from the site without notice. Partisan, pornographic or other inappropriate content, product or service promotion, foul language or bad behavior is expressly forbidden and will be removed.

Decades of Success: The 1970s

Even as a young organization, our work was effective and got noticed. Find out what we did.

Explore Our Timeline


Do you enjoy working with others to help clean the Chesapeake Bay? Do you have a few hours to spare? Whether growing oysters, planting trees, or helping in our offices, there are plenty of ways you can contribute.