Atlantic Menhaden

Commercial menhaden harvestingCommercial fishing boats pull up a net chock-full of menhaden. Photo by John Surrick/CBF Staff.

The Chesapeake's Unsung Hero

They've been called "the most important fish in the sea."

Small, silvery, and packed with nutritional value, menhaden are filter feeders that consume plankton and in turn are food for striped bass and other important fish, as well as marine mammals and sea birds. They are in effect a critical link in the marine food web. But menhaden numbers on the East Coast are near the lowest on record.

Many people have never even heard of this boney, oily, unappetizing fish (also known as bunker or pogy). But without this little unsung hero the Bay's ecosystem would likely collapse. The Bay's other valuable fish like striped bass (rockfish), bluefish, and summer flounder rely heavily on menhaden for nutrition as do whales, osprey, and other fish-eating marine mammals and seabirds.

Further, the Chesapeake Bay has historically been the most important nursery area for Atlantic menhaden. From spring through fall, juveniles as well as adults would be found throughout the entire Bay when the population was healthy.

Why Are they Disappearing?

For hundreds of years, menhaden have been a vital part of our natural and national history. American Indians used menhaden as fertilizer for corn; the early settlers processed them for lamp oil. Then, in the late 19th century, the fishery peaked as menhaden oil replaced whale oil for lighting, and the menhaden population began to collapse.

In the past century, all but one state gradually banned the large scale fishing of this important fish; today, only Virginia allows "reduction" (industrial) menhaden fishing, which takes about 80 percent of the catch coastwide.  The oil and fish meal from the catch goes into paints, cosmetics, animal feeds, and human diet supplements. The other 20 percent is caught and sold as bait for blue crabs, lobster, and for recreational fishing.  Virginia and New Jersey are the leading states in the bait industry. The fishery removes approximately 80,000 tons of menhaden from the Virginia part of the Bay each year.

Graph showing decline of menhaden
Biomass is a measure of weight, in metric tons.
Abundance is a measure of quantity, in billions.

The latest scientific assessment of the population, adopted February 2015, shows the total "biomass" (basically the total mass, or weight, of the fish stock) at a reasonable level due to the belief there are more, older (and therefore larger) menhaden in northern waters than previously thought. But it also shows that the total number of menhaden is low relative to historic patterns. This is important, because it is the number of prey available (abundance) that is key for predators like striped bass and osprey.  Reinforcing this concern is the fact that the number of young menhaden produced in the Bay each year ("recruitment") has been poor for the last 20 years. This low number is of persistent concern and has been linked to the chronic disease problem facing Chesapeake striped bass.

By 2006, the annual industrial catch in the Chesapeake was capped based on concerns about striped bass. Then in May 2010, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) received an alarming scientific report on the status of Atlantic menhaden—confirmation that the species had been systematically overfished for 32 of the previous 54 years. The population was reported to be at its lowest level on record. The analysis was peer reviewed by independent scientists and remains the best available science on Atlantic menhaden.

The fact that this critically important fish's population was at its lowest point on record was a startling wake-up call. So in November of 2011, the ASMFC decided, in an historic vote, to set new standards for how it manages the menhaden fishery.

After thousands of letters and e-mails (including 1,036 from CBF advocates) as well as comments at public ASMFC hearings urging greater conservation, the ASMFC voted to adopt new threshold and target fishing rates to allow the menhaden population to increase to a point where it could support a fishery and fulfill its vital ecological role.

This vote was a significant management action on behalf of Atlantic menhaden and it showed just how important this fish is to the marine ecosystem and to other valuable fisheries.

After a year of preparation and technical analysis the ASMFC met again in December 2012, to adopt a new management plan for applying the new standards. The primary tool of the plan, known as Amendment 2, was a total allowable catch for the coast that was divided up into individual quotas for each state. The quotas were 20 percent lower than recent average catches in each state.

What's Being Done Now?

The latest population assessment was completed in early 2015, and the ASMFC is evaluating how to apply it to management of the fishery.  Some advocates for the fishing industry are urging an increase in the quota, arguing that the assessment shows a healthy population.  CBF and others are urging caution and more thorough analysis to ensure there are enough menhaden to serve as forage for other species in the coastal ecosystem.

While the population does appear in better condition than previously thought, it is still a long way from being healthy and certainly a long way from fulfilling all the forage needs of striped bass and other predators.  The new assessment only shows the status of the menhaden population independent of other species and not its robustness within the food web.

The challenge of the ASMFC is to follow through on its longstanding commitment and adopt guidelines for the fishery that account for menhaden's crucial role in the ecosystem ("ecological reference points"). Only with these tools will it be able to consider changing catch levels without impacting the other species that depend on menhaden as food.

At its May 2015 meeting ASMFC will set a course for incorporating the new science into menhaden management. The result should be a new management plan that will take effect in 2016 or 2017, depending upon how long the process takes and to develop and adopt ecological reference points.

 

 

Virginia Menhaden Legislation Approved!

Commercial menhaden harvesting. Photo by John Surrick/CBF StaffCommercial fishing boats pull up a net chock-full of menhaden. Photo by John Surrick/CBF Staff.

2013 brought a great victory for conservation interests and most importantly, the Chesapeake Bay ecosystem, in the form of overwhelming approval by the state's General Assembly of legislation that brought Virginia into compliance with the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission's revised Interstate Fishery Management Plan. 

Virginia compliance with the coast-wide plan was important not only to restore menhaden numbers and protect marine ecology but to avoid potential federal sanctions that could have hurt Virginia's economy. Sanctions might have included a total shutdown of Virginia's menhaden fishery, which would devastate the livelihoods of hundreds of Virginians employed in the menhaden fishery.

The law reduces Virginia's annual harvest of menhaden in the Bay and off the coast by 20 percent through 2015. That's consistent with the coast-wide conservation plan and a first step toward rebuilding declining stocks of Atlantic menhaden, often called "the most important fish in the sea" because of its critical ecological roles as a filter feeder and forage fish. Studies have shown menhaden numbers are near their lowest levels on record and that the population. Action to better manage menhaden was urgently needed.

This, along with ongoing Chesapeake Clean Water Blueprint efforts to improve water quality, will help ensure the long-term success of both the fish and the fishery.

 

CBF Supports Tighter Standards for Menhaden Fishery

CBF strongly supported the new menhaden fishery management plan enacted by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) in December of 2012 that specified a 20 percent reduction in catch coastwide. Beginning with the 2013 fishing season, all of the Atlantic states that harvest menhaden have strived to meet those quotas, which are the first limits ever imposed on this fishery. The new management plan also adopted the following new standards for the menhaden population, which match the fishing rate standards adopted a year earlier.

  • 15% threshold for "spawining stock biomass"
    The immediate aim of the 20-percent catch reduction is to allow the menhaden population to grow to 15 percent of its original, unfished level. This is the bare minimum threshold for protecting menhaden's ecological role and the standard of ASMFC is seeking to achieve immediately.
  • 30% target for "spawning stock biomass"
    The longer term goal of catch reductions is to allow the menhaden population to grow to 30 percent of its original size. At this level, it has a better chance to reproduce in enough numbers to continue its role as a major food source for predators.

You will begin to receive Bay updates from CBF soon.

In the meantime, join the Bay-friendly conversation on Facebook and Twitter!

Questions that require an answer are marked with  *
   
* Please take a moment to provide the following information so that we may keep you updated on issues and events near you.
   
 E-Mail Address
 First Name
 Last Name
 City
 Zip Code
   
* URL
   
   
* Timestamp
   
     

21 States Against A Clean Chesapeake

Goal: 75,000 signers!

 

1-888-SAVEBAY / 1-888-728-3229

BBB Accredited Charity
GuideStar Exchange Gold Participant Seal
Charity Watch Top-Rated

Bids & ProposalsPrivacy Policy

© 2014 Chesapeake Bay Foundation.
All Rights Reserved.

The Chesapeake Bay Foundation is a nonprofit,
tax-exempt charitable organization under
Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
Donations are tax-deductible as allowed by law.